Skip to Content

Super Tasty Baked Potato Soup

I did a lot of cooking last week. A lot. In addition to making regular meals for my family, I was also in charge of bringing lunch for twenty-five people at my local school district for our twice monthly meeting with the PTO presidents. That’s a lot of food.

Since it was St. Patrick’s Day on Wednesday, I decided that whatever I made had to fit the theme. Corned beef was out, since so many people are anti-corned beef – oh and the smell in a small room for two hours? Yeah, that killed it, too. I was going to do baked potatoes (Irish potato famine, anyone?) with all sorts of toppings and chili. Until the person at the last meeting brought in chili with all the toppings. Ugh.

I wracked my brains and finally came up with something. I made the Irish soda bread I mentioned last week, along with homemade whole wheat baguettes. I did a quick spinach salad with homemade balsamic vinaigrette. Oh, and I made a baked potato soup.

I started making all of the above at 7am the day of the lunch. I had to be out of the house for an event at school at 10am. Start doing the math. Yikes! The soup was great. The second day. Cooking for two hours the day of the event? Well, it was decent, but it’s possible that the potatoes were a little crunchy. Oops. Needless to say, I changed a few things around to account for my little mistake, and the soup – all two huge crockpots of it – has been gone for three days now.

I served it with a couple garnishes – fresh parsley, shredded cheddar, and crumbled bacon. The unexpected winner of the garnishes? The parsley made the best addition of all of them. If you’re making this soup, make sure you put parsley on when you serve it!

Oh, and my other lesson? When traveling with two very full crock pots, use Saran Wrap, not masking tape. Those fill lines on your crock pot are there for a reason. My poor car.

Read This Next:  Oven Roasted Potatoes With Garlic And Spinach

Baked Potato Soup

3 bacon strips, diced
1 onion, chopped
2 cloves garlic, chopped
2 T flour
1/2 t salt
1/2 t pepper
4 c chicken broth
1 baked baking potato, cubed
2-3 baked red potatoes, cubed
1 t basil, dried
1 c half and half
1/2 t Tabasco (or other hot sauce)
1 c shredded cheddar
1/2 c fresh parsley, minced

Bake your potatoes, and cube them. Note that the red potatoes will cook faster than the baking potatoes (you want the baking potatoes for their added starch to thicken the soup).

In a large saucepan (I used my Le Creuset bouillabase pan to make the whole thing), cook bacon until crisp. Remove the bacon and set aside. Keep 1 tablespoon bacon drippings, and dispose of the remainder.

Saute onion and garlic in the drippings until tender. Stir in flour slowly and mix well to ensure it doesn’t clump. Add the salt, basil and pepper; mix well. Cook for 3 minutes to get the raw taste out of the flour.

Gradually add broth. Bring the mixture to a boil. Boil for 2 minutes, stirring regularly. Add the potatoes, cream and hot pepper sauce; heat through but do not boil.

You can also make this without baking the potatoes first. In that case, you’ll want to take the boiled broth to a crock pot. Add the remaining ingredients as directed, and cook on low for 10 or more hours. It really is better the next day!

Garnish with bacon, cheese, and parsley. With all the soup I made, you’d think that I had a picture. Nope. I didn’t take a one. It was so good I only remembered to take one after half the bowl was gone.

And yes, as always – go check out Tempt My Tummy Tuesday with Blessed with Grace!

Enjoy this article? Please share it and save it for later!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Thursday 25th of March 2010

Kelly - Yep, and nice and easy, too! I hope you like it (and make it) :)


Thursday 25th of March 2010

Yummy! I know this would feed my hungry crowd. Thanks Michelle :)


Tuesday 23rd of March 2010

Lisa - Sometimes I don't always use my head... Fortunately, it worked out.

Sherry - Yeah... every time Little Miss gets in, I hear "Mommy, your car smells a little funny." And no time to truly get to the car wash yet. Tomorrow!

Dan - I thought duct tape didn't like moisture though. Am I wrong?

Heather - Yeah. They warn about not filling them more than 2/3 full ;) It was quite yummy!

Alexis - Go for it. I bet your family would eat it up - AND it's not a casserole!

MrsJenB - So glad I'm not the only one who forgets the picture. I always intend to, but ....

Ginger - It is, it is. Even my husband ate multiple days of leftovers.

Pat - Superwoman, ha! Do you know how much more I need to do that I haven't gotten to yet? Egads.

Nichole - Ten to fifteen inches? Oh, I am so done with winter. I can't do this anymore! Go make some soup!

Corrie - A whole high school soccer team? Tripled this recipe might not be enough for them. Yowsers.

Laura - Oh me, too. Unfortunately I put in too much Tabasco for Mister Man, so he couldn't eat it, but generally he does, too. That'll teach me to measure nothing!


Tuesday 23rd of March 2010

LOVE baked potato soup. One of my favorites! Thanks for linking up.

Corrie Howe

Tuesday 23rd of March 2010

Sounds yummy! I will have to start thinking about feeding a high school soccer team again soon. I think I'll keep this in mind for them.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.