This sweet protein sandwich is a unique and fun lunch. Nope, this isn’t just dessert. Fruit and seeds give it nutritional benefit, and yes, Nutella has some decent protein, too!
Mister Man entered a cooking competition on Saturday through our school district. The food service provider sponsored a healthy recipe contest (oh the irony!) where 4th and 5th graders were invited to create sandwich recipes.
Needless to say, my budding chef leapt at the opportunity. I was so proud of him at the district finals where he prepared his sweet protein sandwich, and he’s already preparing to enter next year’s contest – as is Little Miss.
This was a sandwich he truly came up with all on his own. Granted, I helped him a little bit, but that’s only because I vetoed his first option: salami and pineapple.
Once I pointed out that this may not be such a popular option with most people, he started brainstorming other ideas before coming up with this sandwich.
It is definitely not one I ever would have dreamed up on my own! My creative son did and I can vouch for the fact that it’s pretty tasty!
He practiced this sandwich repeatedly, ever since he submitted his recipe to his school and found out that his creation was one of two finalists from his school to compete at the district level.
I love how he got creative and made a strawberry garnish. Why? He felt the plate needed a little something “extra.”
The trick to making the sandwich work is cutting your apples fairly thin and the strawberries just a bit thicker. He got really good at that at home using my sharp knives (under my supervision always), but it took reminders a few times.
Unfortunately, the competition wasn’t quite so easy. He was flustered when they put out his ingredients and his Nutella came out in chunks because they had refrigerated it, and it was hard as a rock.
We finally got them to microwave it so that he could spread it, but that was a challenge for him to adjust to (hello, autism).
He pulled off the leaves of his strawberry garnish because he completely lost his focus, and I could do nothing to help him get back on track but watch.
Couple that with the fact that they gave them “child safe” knives (read: dull butter knives) to use, and we knew there was no way he’d win – have you ever tried to cut apples with a butter knife? thinly? – but he had a blast competing and showing off his sandwich, and that’s all that matters to us.
In the end, he won a bronze medal and a plaque for his entry. Granted, everyone who made the finals won a bronze medal, but who cares?
His sandwich was definitely one of the most creative and judges gave feedback that they would have scored him much higher had he cut his fruit thinner. We don’t care – he had so much fun. Besides, we get to go home and eat this sandwich again and again.
My son created this sweet protein sandwich as a lunch option, but we enjoy Nutella elsewhere, too. My kids love this no bake Nutella cookie, while my favorite is this dessert pizza. Other great options?
How to Make a Sweet Protein Sandwich
Remove the hull from your strawberries. Slice them about a quarter of an inch thick, lengthwise. Slice your apples as thinly as you can. You’ll want 4 or so slices of each apple.
Spread the Nutella on one slice of bread and sprinkle with flax and chia seeds. Press strawberries gently into the sandwich, then top with apple slices.
Place the second slice of bread atop the first and cut the sandwich in half for easy eating. Garnish with another strawberry for fun, if you so choose.
What would you put on your protein sandwich?

Sweet Protein Sandwich
This sandwich is one invented by my 10 year old son for a cooking competition. It's surprisingly tasty and actually fairly healthy!
Ingredients
- 2 slices sourdough bread
- 2 t Nutella
- 2 t flax seeds
- 2 t chia seeds
- 2 strawberries
- 1/3 Granny Smith apple
- 1/3 Gala apple
Instructions
- Remove hull from strawberries. Slice 1/4 inch thick, lengthwise. Slice apples as thinly as possible. You'll want 4 or so slices of each apple.
- Spread Nutella on one slice of bread and sprinkle with flax and chia seeds. Press strawberries gently into sandwich, then top with apple slices.
- Place the second slice of bread atop the first and cut the sandwich in half for easy eating. Garnish with another strawberry for fun, if you so choose.
Recommended Products
As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn a commission from qualifying purchases.
Nutrition Information:
Yield: 1 Serving Size: 1 sandwichAmount Per Serving: Calories: 487Total Fat: 12gSodium: 558mgSugar: 18gProtein: 14g
Tina
Tuesday 29th of May 2018
This is so heartwarming! I'll keep this in mind for my son to have one day, when he gets a bit older!
Michelle
Tuesday 29th of May 2018
Aww thank you! I love that this is *his* recipe, but honestly? It tastes pretty darn good, too!
Baking With Kids: Fluffy Pancakes - Honest And Truly!
Sunday 8th of March 2015
[…] and I suspect there’s a grain of truth to that. It gave him the confidence to enter a cooking competition within our school district where he moved on from our school level competition and placed amongst […]
How To Make A Strawberry Garnish
Thursday 20th of March 2014
[…] the sweet protein sandwich Mister Man created for a local cooking competition? Since he was partly judged on plating, he […]
Angel The Alien
Tuesday 18th of March 2014
That would make a great breakfast sandwich! I'm going to keep it in mind!