Skip to Content

The Most Amazing Marinated Steak You’ll Ever Make

This week, it was really easy to decide what to feature. I had a friend in town, and I happened to make one of my favorite meals — and I often forget about it. This was one of the very first recipes I ever received from someone, shortly after I graduated from college.

The first time I made it, I made it with a then-boyfriend for my parents. We had two and a half pounds of beef tenderloin that we cooked, in addition to veggies and potatoes and biscuits and salad. And between the four of us, we ate it all. It was so good that we just couldn’t stop. And my mom and I are not huge eaters.

I’ve made it periodically since, and it always gets rave reviews. One of my husband’s friends paid it the ultimate compliment by saying there was no point going to a steakhouse because this was better. Huh.

I’ve used this with a variety of cuts of meat. Tenderloin is definitely the best because it’s so tender, but I did NY strip this time, and it was great. The tougher the meat, the longer I marinate. Tenderloin only goes in for two or three hours. NY strip might go in all day.

Yummy Marinated Steak (I know — it actually has no name)

3/4 c soy sauce
1/4 c Worstershire sauce
2 t dry mustard
1 1/2 t pepper
1/2 c vinegar
2 (or more) cloves garlic
1/3 c lemon juice
3/4 c vegetable oil

Get out your blender. Pop in the soy, Worstershire, mustard powder, pepper (ground), vinegar, garlic, and lemon juice. Blend it up until it’s well mixed. Slowly add the vegetable oil while blending until emulsified.

Read This Next:  The BEST Corn on the Cob: Chipotle Grilled Corn

Put your steaks in a Ziplock bag or container, and pour the marinade over them. Store in the fridge to marinate. Turn them periodically. For the last hour, take them out of the fridge to finish. Steaks cook better when close to room temperature, and I promise that an hour out of the fridge isn’t going to make the meat go bad.

Save the marinade after you take out the steaks. Put it in a saucepan and boil. Boil, boil, boil for at least ten minutes.

Grill the steaks to your preferred doneness (if you’re using tenderloin, don’t go past medium rare or a light medium). I sometmes save some of the marinade to baste the steaks, as well, but it isn’t necessary.

Serve the steaks with the marinade sauce as an accompaniment. It’s good. My visiting friend kept dipping his bread in the sauce to sop it up, putting more sauce on his plate and repeating.

I need to make this one again, now that the weather is warming up! Go check out this week’s Tempt My Tummy Tuesday with Blessed With Grace!


Enjoy this article? Please share it and save it for later!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Bacon Cheddar Burgers: A Delicous No Fuss Way to Make Better Burgers

Friday 18th of December 2020

[…] featured Mister Man’s most favoritest yummy marinated steak ever – and I’ll admit to being sort of biased, but I still agree. It was great with my […]

Kefta Kebabs – Delicious Middle Eastern Version Of Meatloaf - Honest And Truly!

Tuesday 23rd of July 2019

[…] in the Midwest, when you think of grilling, hot dogs and hamburgers – and maybe steak, if you’re lucky – are what come to mind. There are so many more options out there, […]

Old Friend

Tuesday 30th of December 2014

Made this again, it seems to be a never fail. Also made homemade crescent rolls. Both will please a crowd!


Wednesday 7th of January 2015

I haven't made this in awhile, but it's always one of my favorites even with different cuts of meats. Homemade crescent rolls I haven't done, however. I may have to add that to my list!


Monday 18th of July 2011

James - I don't generally repost, but I'll link to it sometime soon. Right now, I'm busy putting up the recipes from my trip to Italy. Yum. This recipe is a favorite around here, too - the wee ones eat almost as much as an adult when I serve it ;)


Sunday 17th of July 2011

Made this for some friends the other night and this receipe continues to be a great one. I have enjoyed it from the first time you and I had it many years ago. You should repost this again.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.