Pizza night doesn’t have to stay stuck in the same routine when there are plenty of ways to switch things up. These 23 delicious and unexpected recipes bring new flavors, fun ideas, and easy twists that anyone can make at home without stress. From gooey cheese classics to bold toppings that surprise you, this list shows how simple it can be to rethink pizza night and make it something to look forward to.
Lasagna Pizzas. Photo credit: Honest and Truly.
Air Fryer Tortilla Pizza
Keep pizza night simple with a tortilla pizza that turns golden and crisp in the air fryer in just a few minutes. The thin crust still holds plenty of gooey cheese and toppings, so you get the full pizza flavor without the wait. It’s one of those easy-to-make pizza recipes that shows dinner can be fast and still completely satisfying.
Get the Recipe: Air Fryer Tortilla Pizza
Grilled S’mores Pizza
Add something sweet to pizza night with a grilled s’mores pizza that layers Nutella, marshmallows, and graham crackers on warm crust. The grill melts everything into gooey layers while adding a smoky taste that makes it even better. It’s a fun recipe that proves pizza night can also end with dessert.
Get the Recipe: Grilled S’mores Pizza
Pizza Rolls
Make pizza night exciting with rolls stuffed with chicken, spinach, cheese, and sauce that bake soft inside with a golden outside. The rolls bring all the flavors of pizza together in a handheld bite that feels fun and easy to eat. It’s one of those pizza recipes that keeps people reaching for more every single time.
Get the Recipe: Pizza Rolls
Breakfast Pizza Recipe
Change up the routine with a pizza topped with eggs, gooey cheese, and hearty flavors that feel rich and filling. The crust bakes golden and crisp while the toppings make it a meal that stands strong on its own. It’s an easy-to-make pizza recipe that proves pizza night doesn’t need to look the same.
Get the Recipe: Breakfast Pizza Recipe
Calzones
Bite into calzones loaded with sauce, melted cheese, and plenty of savory fillings wrapped in a crust that bakes soft inside with a slight crunch outside. Every bite gives you that pizza taste in a pocket that feels both fun and filling. It’s one of those pizza recipes that makes pizza night fresh without much effort.
Get the Recipe: Calzones
Asparagus Goat Cheese Pizza
Shake up pizza night with asparagus and goat cheese pizza that blends creamy cheese with tender vegetables. The mix feels light but still satisfying, making it easy to enjoy without missing out on flavor. It’s a creative pizza recipe that proves simple toppings can completely change the night.
Get the Recipe: Asparagus Goat Cheese Pizza
Pizza Pot Pies
Bring comfort to the table with pizza pot pies baked under a flaky crust and filled with chicken, gooey cheese, and rich sauce. The filling bubbles hot and saucy, so every spoonful feels hearty and warm. It’s a pizza recipe that makes pizza night feel cozy and special.
Get the Recipe: Pizza Pot Pies
Chimichurri Pizza
Try a bold twist on pizza night with chimichurri sauce layered over juicy meat, garlic, and herbs. The bright green sauce makes each slice stand out with a flavor that is fresh but still filling. It’s one of those pizza recipes that proves a sauce change can completely switch things up.
Get the Recipe: Chimichurri Pizza
Lasagna Pizzas
Mix two classics in one with lasagna pizzas stacked with cheese, sauce, and plenty of hearty fillings. The layers bake gooey and rich, making every bite taste like comfort food in pizza form. It’s an easy idea that shows pizza night gets better when two favorites team up.
Get the Recipe: Lasagna Pizzas
Chocolate Chip Dessert Pizza
Sweeten the table with chocolate chip dessert pizza baked on a cookie crust that turns soft and chewy. The melted chocolate and marshmallows make each slice rich, fun, and full of flavor. It’s a pizza recipe that makes pizza night double as dessert.
Get the Recipe: Chocolate Chip Dessert Pizza
Garlic Pizza Bread
Mix two favorites in one with garlic pizza bread packed with cheese, pepperoni, and bold garlic flavor. The crust bakes golden, making each bite crisp but still hearty with melted cheese on top. It’s one of those pizza recipes that keeps pizza night simple and crave-worthy.
Get the Recipe: Garlic Pizza Bread
Mexican Steak Pizza
Add spice to your table with Mexican steak pizza loaded with tender beef, bold seasonings, and melted cheese. Each slice tastes rich and hearty, giving you something filling but not complicated to make. It’s a pizza recipe that proves pizza night can be exciting with just a few changes.
Get the Recipe: Mexican Steak Pizza
French Bread Pizza
Keep things quick with French bread pizza that comes out crisp on the outside and gooey inside. The thick bread holds plenty of toppings, making it a fast and filling meal without much work. It’s an easy pizza recipe that makes pizza night stress-free but still delicious.
Get the Recipe: French Bread Pizza
Rainbow Fathead Pizza
Brighten up pizza night with rainbow fathead pizza stacked with colorful vegetables on a chewy low-carb crust. The toppings bring fresh flavor while keeping it fun and satisfying. It’s a pizza recipe that proves pizza night can be both light and bold at the same time.
Get the Recipe: Rainbow Fathead Pizza
Best BBQ Chicken Pizza
Load up on flavor with BBQ chicken pizza topped with smoky sauce, juicy chicken, and plenty of cheese. The mix of tangy and savory flavors makes every slice rich but still easy to prepare. It’s one of those pizza recipes that turns an ordinary night into something you look forward to.
Get the Recipe: Best BBQ Chicken Pizza
Bacon Fathead Pizza Dough
Switch things up with bacon fathead dough that bakes chewy and sturdy enough for all your favorite toppings. The crust carries a hint of bacon in every bite, adding extra flavor without extra work. It’s a creative pizza recipe that keeps pizza night fun and different.
Get the Recipe: Bacon Fathead Pizza Dough
Pizza Cake
Go big with a pizza cake stacked tall with layers of cheese, sauce, and pepperoni baked inside a thick crust. A slice cuts through gooey layers that stay rich, cheesy, and filling from top to bottom. This is one of those pizza recipes that proves pizza night can be bold and unforgettable.
Get the Recipe: Pizza Cake
Air Fryer Pizza Egg Rolls
Crisp up pizza night with egg rolls filled with pepperoni, cheese, and sauce wrapped inside a crunchy shell. They’re easy to dunk in marinara, making them fun for sharing around the table. It’s a pizza recipe that turns pizza night into something playful and tasty.
Get the Recipe: Air Fryer Pizza Egg Rolls
Birria Pizza
Fire things up with birria pizza loaded with spicy meat, melted cheese, and plenty of rich sauce. Each slice is hearty, bold, and perfect for switching up the usual routine. It’s one of those pizza recipes that makes pizza night stand out with unforgettable flavor.
Get the Recipe: Birria Pizza
BBQ Chicken Flatbread Pizza
Keep pizza night fast with BBQ chicken flatbread that bakes crisp and full of smoky flavor. The sauce, cheese, and juicy chicken blend together for a slice that feels both filling and fun. It’s an easy pizza recipe that proves dinner doesn’t need to be complicated to taste great.
Get the Recipe: BBQ Chicken Flatbread Pizza
Shrimp Scampi Pizza
Change the usual toppings with shrimp scampi pizza that mixes garlic, butter, and tender shrimp over a golden crust. The flavors are bold yet simple, making it special without being hard to prepare. It’s one of those pizza recipes that can completely change how you think about pizza night.
Get the Recipe: Shrimp Scampi Pizza
Meatza
Flip tradition with meatza that uses seasoned pork as the crust instead of dough. It’s packed with sauce, cheese, and mushrooms, making it hearty and filling in every bite. It’s a pizza recipe that keeps pizza night easy while offering something totally different.
Get the Recipe: Meatza
Crab Rangoon Pizza
Add a twist with crab rangoon pizza topped with creamy crab, crunchy wonton strips, and gooey cheese. The mix of flavors and textures makes it fun while still being filling. It’s one of those pizza recipes that shows pizza night can still surprise you.
Get the Recipe: Crab Rangoon Pizza