Best White Elephant Gifts People Actually Steal

Every year I go to at least one holiday party with a white elephant exchange, and I’m always hunting for white elephant gifts that people actually want to steal. Our group sets a $25 limit now, but plenty of groups stick to $10 or $20, so I sorted these by budget.

Every gift on this list ships from Amazon, which saves me every time I find out about a party late. I’ve given, received, or watched many of them get stolen myself.

A collage of six novelty products: a Bob Ross Chia Pet, a box of “Cheesy Jokes” cards, a car cup holder for fries, a red-haired microwave cleaner, a strand of multi-colored lights, and bacon-themed bandages.

Some links in this article are affiliate links that may earn me a commission if you purchase through them.

White Elephant Gifts Under $10

A small budget doesn’t mean a boring gift. These cost less than $10 and still get some of the biggest laughs of the night.

And if your group isn’t into laughs, there are plenty of items here that are great gifts anyone would love. You know your group best.

Car French Fry Holder

I gave this one at an exchange, and it was a huge success. Nobody knows they need a French fry holder for the car until they have one, and then they can’t believe they lived without it.

Most Stolen
Car French Fry Holder
Car French Fry Holder

This holder fits in a standard car cup holder and keeps a carton of fries upright so they don’t spill all over the console.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Christmas Lights Charging Cable

It’s the same story as the fry holder. Nobody asks for a charging cable that looks like Christmas lights, and then everybody wants it once they see it plugged in.

Christmas Lights Charging Cable
Christmas Lights Charging Cable

This phone charging cable glows like a string of colored Christmas lights while it charges. Check the listing for the connector type you need.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Motion-Activated Toilet Night Light

I’m avoiding most potty humor because there are so many other gifts that don’t need to stoop to that level, but this one stays on my list because it’s genuinely useful and appreciated, and so are the other few I included. I just think it’s cool that nobody has to flip on the bathroom light in the middle of the night.

Motion-Activated Toilet Night Light
Motion-Activated Toilet Night Light

This motion-activated light hangs on the rim of the toilet bowl and glows in a choice of colors when someone walks in at night.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Cheesy Joke Cards

I love a cheesy dad joke, and these come wrapped like slices of American cheese. Once someone opens the pack, the whole room ends up hearing them.

100 Cheesy Joke Cards
100 Cheesy Joke Cards

This pack holds 100 joke cards designed to look like individually wrapped slices of American cheese.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Bacon Strip Bandages

My daughter loved these bandages, and they’re a hoot. Why should kids have all the fun with silly bandages?

Bacon Strip Bandages
Bacon Strip Bandages

These adhesive bandages are shaped and printed to look like strips of bacon.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Yodeling Pickle

The yodeling pickle is my favorite gift on this list and the bane of my family’s existence. It’s loud and ridiculous, and we all still think it’s hilarious every time somebody presses the button.

Our Favorite
Yodeling Pickle
Yodeling Pickle

Press the button on this plastic pickle, and it yodels. It’s a hilarious twist on the tradition of hiding a pickle in a Christmas tree, but we use it all year long just for the fun of it.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Office Decision Dice

I have a set of procrastination dice that help me decide what to (not) do with my day. They don’t make them anymore, but this is a perfect swap for anyone with a job who needs a chuckle.

Office Decision Dice
Office Decision Dice

These dice settle everyday office decisions with a roll. It’s perfect for when you’re having a bad day to cheer you up, and maybe you can follow its instructions to just head on home.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Poo-Pourri

There’s a bottle of Poo-Pourri in every bathroom in my house, and I see it at friends’ houses, too. It gets a laugh when someone unwraps it, and then it gets used every single day.

Poo-Pourri Toilet Spray
Poo-Pourri Toilet Spray

Spray this in the bowl before you go, and it traps bathroom odors under the surface of the water.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Prank Gift Box

If your group plays rough with stealing, hide your real gift in a prank box that looks like a ridiculous infomercial product. People pick it just to see what’s inside, and the box gets as many laughs as the gift.

Prank Gift Box
Prank Gift Box

This empty gift box looks like the packaging for a ridiculous fake product. Put your real gift inside and wrap it like any other box.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

White Elephant Gifts Under $20

Most groups I know have a limit somewhere around $20. It’s high enough to avoid junk while not being too hard on everyone’s budget.

These gifts look like you spent more than you did, and a couple of them have real staying power once they get home. Some of these are significantly below $20, so you could even double up.

Color-Changing Putty

I grew up playing with Silly Putty, and this version is so much more fun than the one I had. The coolest thing it could do was pick up newsprint to copy it.

This isn’t just for kids either. I love the colors, and it’s so satisfying to fidget with while on a work call.

Color-Changing Putty
Color-Changing Putty

This squishy putty changes color as it warms up in your hands, and it makes a good stress reliever to keep on a desk.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Voice Changer

Is a voice changer useful? Not at all, but the one in our house comes out far more often than you’d expect, especially when I’m calling my kids for dinner or reminding them about chores.

Voice Changer
Voice Changer

This handheld voice changer switches between several different sound effects, and it runs on batteries so it goes anywhere.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Moon Lamp

I bought a moon lamp for a friend’s adult daughter to use as a night light, and she absolutely loves it. It’s soothing, a little unexpected, and pretty enough to leave out all year.

Moon Lamp
Moon Lamp

This lamp looks like a small full moon, right down to the craters, and the remote changes the color and brightness.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Self-Care Nifty Note Pad

I love these Nifty Notes, and the company makes a bunch of different versions that remind us to do something for ourselves. They’re small on their own, so pick up two or three and bundle them for a fuller gift.

Self-Care Nifty Note Pad
Self-Care Nifty Note Pad

This notepad looks like an old-school prescription pad, with funny self-care prompts to check off on every sheet.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Funny Bathroom Sign

My mom has a sign like this in her guest bathroom, and she gets comments on it all the time. She got it for free and would never have bought it for herself, which is exactly what you want in a white elephant gift.

Funny Bathroom Sign
Funny Bathroom Sign

This 12-inch square sign gives the bathroom a five-star review.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Light-Up Lightsaber Chopsticks

I bought these for my Star Wars-obsessed son a few years ago, and they were a favorite gift. We still pull them out whenever we make Asian food at home.

Light-Up Lightsaber Chopsticks
Light-Up Lightsaber Chopsticks

These chopsticks glow like lightsabers in a few different colors, and they make practicing with chopsticks a lot more fun for kids.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Mini Wacky Inflatable Tube Guy

This one cracks me up just thinking about it. Set it on a coworker’s desk, and the whole office ends up stopping by to watch.

Mini Wacky Inflatable Tube Guy

This desk-size version of the waving inflatable tube guy from car lots dances and flails when you turn it on.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Aromatherapy Shower Steamers

Shower steamers are a good pick when your group wants something a little nicer than a gag gift. They’re also one of the few gifts on this list that get used up, so nobody has to find a place for them afterward.

Aromatherapy Shower Steamers
Aromatherapy Shower Steamers

Set one of these tablets on the shower floor away from the stream, and it fills the shower with scent as it dissolves.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Sriracha: The Game

We love playing games as a family, and my friend group has a monthly game night, too. This one gets loud fast, and it’s great to break out right after the gift exchange wraps up. Anyone who puts Sriracha on everything will want to steal it.

Sriracha: The Game
Sriracha: The Game

This fast card-slapping game is built around the famous hot sauce, and it works for kids, teens, and adults.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

White Elephant Gifts Under $30

Our group raised its limit to $25, and I see more groups doing the same. These gifts fill out a bigger budget without blowing past it.

Bob Ross Chia Pet

Chia Pets are a campy classic most of us forgot about until someone brings one to a party. Put Bob Ross on it, and people start plotting who’s going to steal it.

Bob Ross Chia Pet
Bob Ross Chia Pet

This planter is shaped like Bob Ross, and the chia seeds sprout into his famous hair in a week or two.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Burrito Blanket

A friend gave me a burrito blanket years ago, and it’s still the softest, most fun blanket I own. My kids kept stealing mine, so now they each have their own.

Most Stolen
Burrito Blanket
Burrito Blanket

This round fleece blanket is printed to look like a giant flour tortilla, so you can roll yourself up like a burrito.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

I Hate People Sequin Pillow Cover

A couple of years ago, I brought Joey from Friends sequin pillows to our exchange, and they got stolen the max three times. Sequin pillows are a sure bet at an exchange, and this one gets an even bigger laugh.

Let the world know how you feel, or keep it hidden. I won’t judge either way.

I Hate People Sequin Pillow Cover
I Hate People Sequin Pillow Cover

This reversible sequin pillow cover reveals an I Hate People message when you brush the sequins one way. The insert is sold separately.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Exploding Kittens Card Game

I bought this game for my family years ago, and it’s a huge hit. We love to play it, and it always gets a little rowdy and competitive. It’s also one of the few white elephant gifts that gets played the same night.

Exploding Kittens Card Game
Exploding Kittens Card Game

Players draw cards and try to avoid the exploding kitten in this quick card game for two to five players.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Punny Tea Towels

I gave punny tea towels to a friend who loves tea towels, and she was thrilled. These retro-designed towels are silly enough for the exchange and useful enough to hang in the kitchen.

Punny Tea Towels
Punny Tea Towels

This set of kitchen towels has a different food pun printed on each one.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Heated Lunch Box

Anyone who brings lunch to work will use this every day, making it a smart pick for an office exchange. Nobody has to wait in line for the break room microwave anymore.

Heated Lunch Box
Heated Lunch Box

This electric lunch box plugs into a wall outlet or a car charger and warms food in a leakproof, removable stainless steel container.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Wearable Blanket Hoodie

This is an easy gift for almost anybody, since one size fits most and everyone gets cold on the couch in the winter. I’d happily steal it myself to stay warm when I work at home.

Wearable Blanket Hoodie
Wearable Blanket Hoodie

This oversized hoodie is lined with sherpa fleece and feels like wearing a blanket.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Rechargeable Hand Warmers

These are great for anyone who walks the dog, coaches a winter sport, or waits for the train in the cold. They’re the kind of practical gift people are secretly thrilled to take home.

I bought sets for my kids who have to walk to class in college and another for my mom who suffers from Raynaud’s syndrome. Why I haven’t gotten a set for myself… well, maybe I’ll be lucky this year.

Rechargeable Hand Warmers
Rechargeable Hand Warmers

These hand warmers heat up fast and recharge over USB, so there’s nothing to throw away after a cold day outside.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Rechargeable Wine Opener Set

Every group has at least one wine lover, and they’ll go after this one. Whoever takes it home will use it at the very next party.

Rechargeable Wine Opener Set
Rechargeable Wine Opener Set

This rechargeable electric wine opener pulls a cork with the push of a button, and the set includes extra wine accessories.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Adjustable Candle Warmer Lamp

Candle lovers will be thrilled with this one, and it’s a safer pick for anyone with kids or pets at home. Their favorite candles will last longer, too, since nothing burns down the wick.

Adjustable Candle Warmer Lamp
Adjustable Candle Warmer Lamp

This lamp melts the top of a jar candle with a warm bulb, so the room smells like the candle without an open flame. The brightness adjusts, too.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Rechargeable Neck Fan

A fan might seem like an odd gift in December, but whoever ends up with it will thank you come summer. It’s also a lifesaver for anyone who runs warm all year or has a vacation coming up.

Rechargeable Neck Fan
Rechargeable Neck Fan

This bladeless fan rests around your neck and runs on a rechargeable battery to keep you cool on hot days, at theme parks, and while you travel.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Foodie White Elephant Gifts

This is a food blog, so of course I have a section for the cooks (or just anyone who loves food) in your group. These kitchen gadgets are useful but still silly, and the edible ones are half the fun to open.

Angry Mama Microwave Cleaner

Angry Mama is a cult favorite among my friends. So many people already know about her, and we all love her.

Our Favorite
Angry Mama Microwave Cleaner
Angry Mama Microwave Cleaner

Fill this fuming mom with vinegar and water, microwave her, and the steam loosens grime so you can wipe the microwave clean.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Triceratops Taco Holder

Several of my friends own this triceratops taco holder, and they love it. Fill it with my Honey Habanero Ground Beef Tacos, and it’s adorable on the table.

Triceratops Taco Holder
Triceratops Taco Holder

This triceratops holds tacos upright between the plates on its back so they don’t tip over.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Blooming Onion Maker

I once went to a work exchange where we could only bring things from home, and someone brought a blooming onion maker they’d never used. It was the most stolen gift of the night, and I still kind of want one of my own.

Most Stolen
Blooming Onion Maker
Blooming Onion Maker

This kit includes a cutter and a breading container for making a blooming onion at home.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

DIY Candy Bento Kit

These Japanese candy kits are half science experiment and half snack, and adults have just as much fun with them as kids. Grab a few different ones and bundle them for a bigger gift.

DIY Candy Bento Kit
DIY Candy Bento Kit

Mix the powders with water to make a tiny bento box out of candy. Each kit includes a tray and everything you need except the water.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Loch Ness Monster Ladle

I’ve bought this ladle for friends before, and it’s always a hoot. It’s the kind of kitchen gadget nobody buys for themselves, but it’s hilarious to see her swimming in your soup.

Loch Ness Monster Ladle
Loch Ness Monster Ladle

This ladle is shaped like the Loch Ness Monster and stands upright on its own feet in the pot or on the counter.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Gingerbread Man Mini Waffle Maker

A mini waffle maker gets used all year, and this one is festive enough for a holiday exchange. Pair it with a bottle of good syrup if your budget has room.

Gingerbread Man Mini Waffle Maker
Gingerbread Man Mini Waffle Maker

This mini waffle maker makes four-inch waffles shaped like a gingerbread man.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Giant Gummy Worm

The reaction when someone unwraps a gummy worm the size of their arm is worth every penny. Bring it to a group that loves candy, and watch it get stolen. I’ve given my kids giant gummy mice and bears and army figures before, and they always love them.

Giant Gummy Worm
Giant Gummy Worm

This giant gummy worm weighs about three pounds and comes in several flavor combinations.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Want to bring something homemade instead? Check with your group first, since some exchanges only allow store-bought gifts. A tin of my Nut-Free English Toffee never makes it home.

How to Play White Elephant

Every group plays a little differently, so agree on the rules before anyone opens a gift. This is how our group plays.

Everyone brings one wrapped gift within the price limit and adds it to the pile. Then everybody draws a number from a hat to set the order, start with the youngest or whoever’s birthday is closest, or choose whoever answers the most questions correctly in a quiz.

The first person picks a gift from the pile and opens it in front of everyone. Each person after that either opens a new gift or steals one that’s already been opened.

If someone steals your gift, you get the same choice to open a new gift or steal from someone else. We use a three-steal rule, so once a gift has been stolen three times, it stays with its third owner.

The first person never got a chance to steal, so they get one at the very end. They can swap their gift for any gift that isn’t locked in yet, and then the game is over.

Try Gift Exchange Dice for a Twist

Want to shake things up? Swap the stealing for gift exchange dice.

Draw numbers for the order the same way, and then each person picks a wrapped gift in order, but no one opens it until everyone has an unopened gift.

After that, each person rolls the dice in order for one round (or do it twice if everyone is enjoying themselves). Follow the instructions for what it lands on, like trading with the person on your left, everyone passing gifts to the right, or picking two people to swap.

It makes the whole game more entertaining, especially with a group that knows each other well. People may not end up with the gift they really want, though, so know your audience before you bring them out.

Gift Exchange Dice
Gift Exchange Dice

These big three-inch dice turn any gift exchange into a game of chance, with a different swap instruction printed on every side.

Check the Latest Price
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

What Is a White Elephant Gift?

A white elephant gift is a funny, quirky, or unexpected present that you bring to a group gift exchange. It should be something people want once they see it, even if they’d never buy it for themselves. It shouldn’t be junk, though, and that’s a fine line to walk.

Is White Elephant Supposed to Be Funny?

Usually, yes. Most groups want gifts that get a laugh, but the best ones are funny and useful, so people fight over them instead of trying to get rid of them. Gag gifts work when they’re clever without being cruel, crude, or too juvenile for your crowd.

Why Is It Called a White Elephant Gift?

The name comes from a story about the kings of Siam, now Thailand. Legend says a king would give a rare white elephant to someone who displeased him, and since the animal was sacred, the person couldn’t refuse it or put it to work, so it cost a fortune to keep.

Historians haven’t found solid proof that it ever happened, but the story stuck. Today, a white elephant means a gift that’s more trouble than it’s worth, though a good white elephant gift is one people actually want.

What Are Other Names for White Elephant?

You might hear Yankee Swap, Dirty Santa, Thieving Elves, the Grinch Game, Cutthroat Christmas, or Shifty Santa. I have friends who had no idea what I meant by white elephant until we figured out we were talking about the same game. The name can hint at how seriously a group takes stealing.

How Much Should You Spend on a White Elephant Gift?

Spend within a couple of dollars of your group’s limit. Going way under makes your gift look skimpy next to everyone else’s, and going over makes people uncomfortable. Most groups don’t count sales tax toward the limit.

Can You Regift for a White Elephant Exchange?

You can if your group allows it, as long as the gift is new, clean, and complete. Some groups even make regifting the theme for the year.

What Should You Not Bring to a White Elephant Exchange?

Skip anything overtly sexual, political, or mean-spirited, along with anything racist, sexist, or demeaning. Never bring something broken, dirty, or missing pieces. If you wouldn’t be happy taking it home, don’t bring it.

Collage of 8 photos with text 25 amazing white elephant gifts.

I am a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.

Enjoy this article? Please share it and save it for later!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.